Build Power for the Long Haul: Hardy Merriman Brings Democracy Defense Strategies to Billings

In May, the Yellowstone County Democratic Central Committee welcomed Hardy Merriman to Billings for a free community workshop on democratic organizing and resistance strategy. Merriman, who has spent decades working with human rights movements internationally, has in recent years turned his focus to democratic backsliding within established democracies, including right here in the United States.

If you missed the event, the full workshop is available on YouTube. Here’s a look at what he covered.

The Challenge We’re In

Merriman opened by framing the current political moment clearly: public confidence in the federal government has hovered around 20% since the 2009 financial crisis, creating fertile ground for authoritarian tactics. One of those tactics, he noted, is deliberately flooding the information ecosystem to overwhelm and exhaust citizens. His message: don’t let that work. The goal in this phase isn’t immediate total victory. It’s building internal unity and strategic capacity so the movement gets stronger through the act of fighting.

Three Phases of Pushback

Merriman laid out a framework for understanding where movements are and what they need to do next:

  • Phase 1 is about slowing the damage and building power.
  • Phase 2 focuses on protecting democratic outcomes, including elections, drawing on a recent example of communities mobilizing to enforce a state supreme court race result in North Carolina.
  • Phase 3 is what comes after: continuing to organize even after a win, because movements that stay active post-election historically achieve larger democratic gains.

What Movements Can Actually Control

One of the most useful sections of the workshop was Merriman’s breakdown of internal movement health indicators. Rather than tracking progress through news cycles, he encouraged groups to honestly assess themselves on five factors:

  • unity across sectors,
  • strategic capacity beyond just protest,
  • nonviolent discipline (including managing burnout),
  • mass participation with low barriers to entry, and
  • targeted pressure on institutions.

The Pillars of Support Framework

Merriman offered a strategic lens for understanding how power actually works: those in power hold no intrinsic authority. They depend entirely on the cooperation of institutions around them, including the judiciary, media, corporations, and bureaucracies. Organizers who map those relationships can find cracks, tensions, and points of leverage.

He applied this framework in detail to Immigration and Customs Enforcement, walking through how activist campaigns have targeted private contractors, data aggregators, and university contracts, and how that kind of targeted pressure differs from broad opposition. He also demonstrated how public federal spending data can surface local contractors, using an example from Bozeman, to show that this kind of research is accessible to any organized group.

The Montgomery Bus Boycott and Strategic Focus

The civil rights classic came up in the context of targeting: choosing one highly specific, logistically vulnerable pillar creates systemic leverage. Merriman used it to illustrate why strategic focus matters more than comprehensive opposition.

Backfire: Turning Repression Into Power

The final major framework was “backfire,” drawn from the work of scholar Brian Martin. When authoritarian or abusive actors overreach, their actions can produce the opposite of the intended effect, strengthening their targets and fracturing their own support. But this doesn’t happen automatically. Merriman outlined the five tactics abusers use to prevent backfire, including cover-ups, discrediting targets, and using delayed investigations to drain momentum.

The counter-strategy he calls the 5 Rs:

  • Reveal the injustice quickly and visually;
  • Redeem targets using community validators;
  • Reframe the story around systemic and human impacts;
  • Redirect outrage into organized action; and
  • Resist internal fracturing and attempts to buy off the movement.

A Note on Nonviolence

Merriman closed with a firm strategic (not just moral) defense of nonviolence. The data is clear: movements that shift toward violence are statistically far more likely to face mass atrocities, and they hand authoritarian actors exactly the pretext they need to crack down.

Watch the Full Workshop

This is the kind of strategic, grounded, practical analysis that helps organizers think clearly in a chaotic moment. We’re grateful to Hardy Merriman for bringing this work to Billings, and to everyone who attended.

Fall BBQ at the Zoo!

Enjoy a home-cooked dinner and camaraderie with fellow Democrats. Seating is limited, so get your tickets now!

Become a Sustaining Member

Your support helps us knock more doors, answer more calls, change more minds to build a stronger community for Yellowstone County and Montana.

Activist sign with butterfly reads “change begins here” held by a gloved hand in a peaceful protest
Days
Hours

Join Us

38th Annual Harry S Truman Democratic Dinner

Come for the keynote. Stay for the community, the conversation, the silent auction, the raffle, and the reminder that we are many — and we are gaining momentum!