Everybody knows about coattails: a strong candidate at the top of the ticket pulls the rest of the ballot along. It runs both directions.
In 2021, Run for Something and BlueLabs Analytics compared 2020 precincts where a Republican ran unopposed for the statehouse against precincts where both parties fielded a candidate. Simply having a Democrat on the ballot raised turnout at the top of the ticket by 0.4 to 2.3 percent. In Georgia, where Biden carried the state by about 11,000 votes, they estimated down-ballot Democrats netted him as many as 22,000. They found no downside anywhere: running a Democrat never cost the ticket, even in seats with no path to victory. Their conclusion was two words. Run everywhere.
Fractions of a percent sound like rounding error until you look at a Montana ballot. Local districts here hold a few thousand voters. Races get decided by dozens, and it’s not rare for somebody to lose a seat by a handful of votes. At that scale, half a percent is the whole margin.
The reason is the door
Statewide campaigns run on a budget and a map, so by necessity, they campaign in targeted neighborhoods based on data that tells them who and how someone is likely to vote.
A legislative candidate knocks their whole district. A Montana House race covers a few thousand households, and a candidate with a handful of volunteers can reach most of them in person over a summer.
The researchers found the two maps rarely line up. Precincts where a statewide campaign needs turnout and precincts where a legislative candidate needs votes are different places. Local organizing fills the gaps the statewide operation cannot afford to work.
And a doorstep conversation does not sort itself by race. Somebody who talks to a neighbor running for the statehouse and then fills out their ballot is voting in every contest printed above it. One ballot, returned, counts everywhere at once.
What that looks like here
Our candidates are running that kind of campaign right now across the whole county. They are knocking doors that no other campaign on this ballot has the capacity to reach, and every one of those conversations is working for the whole ticket.
Which is why we support Democratic candidates, all of them, up and down the ballot. The strength of the ticket comes from every race being contested and every district being worked. Cherry-picking which candidates deserve support would undercut the exact thing that makes it work.
The most common reason people give for sitting out a legislative race is that the big races matter more. The research says that is backwards. Two hours on a Saturday in your own neighborhood in support of a state legislature or county campaign is a contribution to that race and to everything above it.
Find your district and the candidates running in it at our Voter Action Center. Then come see us at 1501 14th St W, Suite 1521, Monday through Friday 10 to 1 or weekends 11 to 1.