No Montana city or county can regulate single-use plastics. Billings cannot. Bozeman tried, by a vote of its own residents, and a 2021 state law stopped it.
On December 14 and 15, a jury in Helena will hear a challenge to that law, House Bill 407. The Legislature that convenes in January can repeal it whatever the jury decides.
What HB 407 does
HB 407 bars local governments from adopting or enforcing any rule on “auxiliary containers,” the statute’s term for plastic bags, cups, bottles, straws, foam takeout boxes, and other single-use packaging. The ban covers every route a community has: a city council ordinance, a county resolution, and a citizen initiative, where residents gather signatures to put a law on the local ballot themselves.
Bozeman is the test case. In November 2024, 63 percent of Bozeman voters approved an ordinance ending plastic carryout bags and foam containers at local businesses and making straws available only on request. The margin was about 8,000 votes. The ordinance has never taken effect.
How it became law
The Montana House endorsed HB 407 by a vote of 64 to 35 in February 2021. The House has 100 members. Every Democrat voted no, joined by two Republicans. The Senate passed the bill on March 31, and it became law that April.
Supporters argued that businesses need one statewide standard instead of a patchwork of local rules. The Legislature has adopted no statewide plastics standard since.
Legislators tried to repeal the law in 2023 (HB 413) and again in 2025 (HB 160). Neither bill reached the governor’s desk.
What the Montana Constitution says
- Article II, Section 3 lists the rights every Montanan is born with. “The right to a clean and healthful environment” is among them.
- Article IX, Section 1 puts a duty on government and residents alike: “The state and each person shall maintain and improve a clean and healthful environment in Montana for present and future generations.” It also directs the Legislature to provide adequate remedies that protect the environment from degradation.
- Article XI lets cities and counties govern themselves, within limits the Legislature sets. A city with a self-government charter, Bozeman among them, may use any power that state law has not taken away.
The Montana Supreme Court relied on that limit in December 2024, ruling that the Legislature may restrict what local voters do by initiative the same way it restricts city councils. The justices left one question undecided: whether HB 407 itself violates the right to a clean and healthful environment.
What the jury will hear
That undecided question goes to trial in Lewis and Clark County District Court. Cottonwood Environmental Law Center, a Bozeman nonprofit, brought the case with several co-plaintiffs, Billings residents among them.
Juries decide disputed facts, and judges decide what the law means. Cottonwood says it will show jurors that lawmakers heard testimony about plastic in Montana’s rivers and wildlife before they voted, then blocked local action without offering any of their own. Cottonwood also says a win would let Bozeman’s ordinance take effect. The State of Montana is defending the law and has argued that HB 407 infringes on no constitutional right.
A verdict for the plaintiffs would strike one statute, and either side can appeal to the Montana Supreme Court.
Where Yellowstone County Democrats stand
The central committee has taken no position on the lawsuit. We support what the Montana Democratic Party platform, adopted in June, says about the issues underneath it:
- A clean and healthful environment is a constitutional right, and Montanans have a right to take part when their governing bodies make decisions.
- Local control is a principle of good government.
- Citizens belong in environmental decisions at every level.
- Montana should end the manufacture and use of plastic shopping bags.
A platform is a statement of party positions. It is not law, and it binds no legislator. Read the platform.
The Legislature can act whatever the jury decides
Montana’s Legislature meets for 90 days in odd-numbered years, and the next session opens in January 2027. Repealing HB 407 takes a majority vote in each chamber and the governor’s signature. No court ruling is required.
Courts settle one statute at a time, after the harm, at the expense of the people who sue. Legislators can return this decision to every city and county in Montana with a single bill.
Three things you can do
- Ask your legislators where they stand. Look up your House and Senate districts at the Montana Voter Portal, find their contact information at leg.mt.gov, and ask whether they will vote to repeal HB 407 in 2027.
- Bring it to Billings City Council. Ask council members to pass a resolution urging the Legislature to return this decision to cities. Bozeman’s city commission passed a resolution supporting a single-use plastics ban in 2022.
- Follow the trial. It runs December 14 and 15 in Helena and is open to the public. We will report the result on this site and in our newsletter.


